Avoid "Chinglish"Written by Scott Dreyer
(Reading level: Intermediate)
What is "Chinglish"?
Where does Chinglish come from?
Before words can come out of your mouth, theÂ idea hasÂ to first form in your brain. So far so good. The problem comes when you try to speak in a foreign language, especially one you are still new at. In those cases, we tend to think up an idea in our mind, in our native language, and then translate it into the foreign language. This is where problems can happen. The normal method is to learn individual words in the new language, and then try to translate them directly. However, between languages, many ideas, words or phrases do not translate directly. Let me explain with some examples. When I was in 9th grade, I had my first real experience with foreign languages, in German I. I had learned that "happy" was "froelich," and "birthday" was "Geburtstag." So, quite impressed with my new German, I wished someone "Froelich Geburtstag." That was the direct translation, yes...but I was wrong. Germans do not say it that way. In German, the actual blessing is "Alles Gute zum Geburtstag." The German phrasing translates more like, "All the best for your birthday." Fast forward about ten years, and I was then in Taiwan learning Mandarin Chinese. Same story. I had been there for a few months and had been picking up some words and phrases. A friend's birthday was approaching, and I knew the word for happy was 快樂 (kuaile) and birthday was 生日 (shengri). So, quite ready to demonstrate how much Chinese I had learned, I smiled and wished her a hearty 快樂 生日 (kuaile shengri)! But instead of the smiles I thought I was sure to get for my "good Chinese," I got wide eyes and looks of shock. "Oh no, you can't say that! It's 生日 快樂 (shengri kuaile)."
"Birthday Happy!?" For a split second I mentally protested. "'Birthday Happy' doesn't make any sense!" I thought to myself. Then I realized it. It's probably best not to argue against 5,000 years of culture and language. If it's literally Birthday Happy to the 1.4 billion Chinese speakers, then it will have to be Birthday Happy to me, and that was an important moment in my Mandarin language acquisition. Do not think too much in your mother tongue and try to translate directly word for word. Instead, try to learn actual phrases and ideas in the foreign language, and you will pick it up faster. (See the example? "Pick it up" can literally mean "to lift something with your hands," but it can also mean "to learn something new.")
How can I stop Chinglish?
So, the list begins below. These examples are in no particular order of importance or category. I will simply post them in the order that I think of them or they come up in some of our ESL classes. To encourage you to visit this blog often to see new examples of Chingish, I will post recent examples at the top, right below the stars (*****). For years I have been explaining these points and many more in my ESL classes. Now, here begins a list for all to see and learn from. Enjoy!
1. Read/Look/See/Watch - This is another example where you have one Chinese word (看), but English has several words to express this. These words all involve receiving input and images from the eyes, which then go to the brain. However, these words also involve some differences, which I will try to explain, with sample sentences for each.
- Reading something daily is a good life habit.
B. Look:This usually means to direct your eyes and attention to something new.
C. See: to physically perceive and look at with the eyes (Note: this sounds the same as "sea," a small ocean, and the letter "C.")
D. Watch: This is close to "see," but a little different. "Watch" implies to continually look at something for an extended time. (Note: this is also a noun, the small clock you wear on your wrist.)
- It's fun to watch birds fly into and out of a bird feeder.
2. Color - In Chinese, you add the word "color" after the actual color. So, the Chinese 白色 should be "It is white (correct) NOT It is white color (wrong). Examples:
3. Yesterday night / Last night - The Chinese for "yesterday" is 昨天, and you CAN say "yesterday morning" or "yesterday afternoon," but you cannot say "yesterday night."
4. Future times - We use the word "next" much when discussing times or events. In English you can talk about: next week, next month, next semester, even next year. But, we NEVER repeat the word next. So, if this is the first week of October, then the second week is next week, but we call the third week of October 下下個星期 "Two weeks from now" or you can also say "the week after next." Do NOT say "next next week."
I am writing this post on a Wednesday. So, tomorrow is Thursday. But what do we call Friday? The Chinese call it 後天, but in English we do not have a specific name for it, so we call it "the day after tomorrow" or "two days from now." How about 大後天? We do not have a specific name for that in English either, so we just call that "three days from now." Maybe this helps:
5. I have ever been there. - We use "ever" in a question, such as:
- I have ever seen a Blue Jay. (Chinglish) I have seen a Blue Jay before. (right)
6. Been to there, been to here - This is a bit tricky. Normally when you say where you have visited, you add a "to" before the place.
7. When to use "to" with a verb...and when NOT to.
Use "to" before an infinitive verb (不定式動詞). That is, use "to" before a verb in its normal form, without -ing, -ed, -es, etc. For example:
8. Live vs. Stay. - This is a common problem. In Chinese, you use the verb "to live" for a place you spend the night, for either a short or long time. In English, we normally use "live" for a place where you have lived for a long time, as your main residence. For example: "I lived in beautiful Roanoke, Virginia until I went away to college." This implies a place where you have all or most of your clothes, furniture, etc. For a shorter time, from one night up to maybe several weeks or months, in English we use the verb "stay." For example: "Mom, can I stay at my friend's house tonight?" "The kids from China stayed with us for four weeks for their summer camp." This implies your home is somewhere else, but you are living temporarily at another place, like a friend's house, hotel, etc.
9. Move house. - The literal Chinese is: "They next month will move house." But in English, we infer that one is changing one's residence, so we just say, "They will move next month." Now you might be thinking: isn't that the same as just "moving around." We can say: "The wind moved the dry leaves." "Mom moved the chair across the room." "The teacher yelled because the students kept moving." Yes, you are right. It is the same verb. But from the context we can normally figure out that a person or family is moving from one place to live to another.
Now, for MORE fun. Yes, you CAN actually say, "move house," but that means to physically dig up the house, put it on a truck, and drive it down the road to a new location.
10. Marry with. - In Chinese, we literally say "He with her got married." But in English, we normally do not use "with." So just say, "He married her" or "He will marry his high school sweetheart, Margaret."
11. Use the plural noun when you are discussing something in a general sense.
12. Explaining frequency. - Chinese gives the time frame first then the frequency, but English does just the opposite.
13. English uses "it" a lot, especially in places where Chinese uses the verb have.
14. Crazy prepositions (介詞). These are the little words that show relationships, such as: in, under, below, on top of, between, next to, in front of, etc.
- It's confusing to beginners. (wrong) It's confusing for beginners. (right)
- Stay in the trail. (wrong) Stay on the trail. (right)
English is a crazy language, and sometimes the prepositions do not make any sense. We say in a car, on a boat, on a plane, on a bus, in a trailer, on a train, on the road, in the driveway.
Learn more about prepositions in this video. 15. Few people vs. little people. - "Few" means a small number, but "little" means small in size.
- "We are all in the same room because there are little people here." (wrong) "We are all in the same room because there are few people here." (right)
16. Expect vs. looking forward to. - These can both have the same Chinese meaning (期待), but in English they are different.
17.Comparisons: With most short adjectives, of one or two syllables, we usually add an -er to show a comparison. Examples: shorter, taller, prettier, uglier, faster, slower, quicker, cheaper. However, "good" is an oddball. The comparison form is "better."
Generally, for adjectives of three syllables or longer, we add "more." Examples: more convenient, more understandable, more reliable, more expensive.
18. cook vs. cooker. This is one of my favorite examples, and it came up in a conversation class today. English is a crazy language. Many jobs in English DO end with -er or -or (teacher, manager, waiter, presenter, builder, lawyer, carpenter, hairdresser, porter, director, doctor, tailor.) However, cooker is not one of them. In English, a cooker is an electric device used to cook things. Most Chinese kitchens have a rice cooker. In contrast, the job where a person cooks is a cook. (You can also call this person a chef.) So, the cooker is the thing, and the cook is the person.
Three cooks, NOT three cookers
Answers: 1. E
3. C Yes, I like it here.
4. C I really look forward to Christmas. OR I am really looking forward to Christmas. (continuous tense)
5. C We named our cat "snowball," because she is white.
6. C We watched a movie last night.
8. C I am going back to China the week after next. OR I am going back to China two weeks from now.
10. C I am going there now.
12. C Yes, I have been there before.
13. C When I went to LA, I stayed in a nice hotel for three nights.
14. C Do you want to go shopping this weekend? (better) OR Do you want to shop this weekend?
15. C Do you like to speak English?
17. C The Smiths have been our neighbors for many years, but they will move next next week.
18. C Our son has piano lessons two times a week. OR Our son has piano lessons twice a week.
19. C Learning English from DreyerCoaching.com is better than going to a cram school, because you can learn at home and your teachers speak American English. (Pardon the self-promotion!)
20. C Her birthday is in October.
21. C Hurry up! Mom is already in the car and she wants to leave now.
22. C We are tired because we were on the train for more than five hours.
24. C Do you want to go out tonight or just stay home and watch some TV?
25. E How did you do? Count the number you got correct.
25 correct - Congratulations! You are at native-speaker level!
23-24 correct - Great! You are near native-speaker level!
20-22 - Good job! You getting close to native-speaker level!
19 or under - Keep on working on your English!
Do you want to learn to avoid MORE common Chinglish errors? Join one or our online English classes! Plus, get my award-winning book, Write Like A Champion (美國老師教你寫出好英文) where one whole chapter is devoted to just this topic! Find out more about my book and get your own copy here.
A licensed teacher in the US state of Virginia since 1987, Scott Dreyer has been helping Chinese speakers improve their English since 1989. Dreyer lived in Taiwan from 1989-1999 where he learned Mandarin, met his wife, started his family, and realized he loved working with Chinese students. He became an award-winning author and started teaching ESL online in 2008. Dreyer and his wife and their four adult children make their home in the beautiful Roanoke Valley in the Blue Ridge Mountains of Virginia.dreyercoaching.com/en/about/scott-dreyer
Latest from Scott Dreyer
Leave a comment
Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.